After years of silence and submission to Vladimir Putin, some of Russia’s wealthiest oligarchs are beginning to consider what the country might look like without him in power.
According to a BBC analysis, parts of Russia’s economic elite increasingly view the current political system as a dead end and are beginning to discuss possible scenarios for the country’s future after Putin’s departure.
On February 24, 2022, just hours after Russia launched its full-scale invasion of Ukraine, Putin summoned the country’s wealthiest billionaires to the Kremlin to secure their support for the war. None dared to openly challenge him.
One person familiar with the meeting described the atmosphere as one in which men who normally saw themselves as “alpha males on steroids” had turned into submissive and almost desperate schoolchildren in Putin’s presence.
Since coming to power in 2000, Putin has gradually brought Russia’s economic elite under his control. One of the most prominent examples is Mikhail Khodorkovsky, once Russia’s richest man, who spent a decade in prison while repeatedly denying the accusations against him.
Today, Russia has 155 billionaires with a combined fortune of nearly $700 billion, according to Forbes. Those who criticised the war suffered financial losses, while oligarchs who remained loyal to the Kremlin benefited from lucrative state contracts connected to the war effort.
“They are rich because they have connections to Putin, not the other way around,” former Kremlin adviser Dmitry Nekrasov told the BBC.
However, this longstanding silence now appears to be showing signs of fracture.
Growing signs of dissatisfaction among the business elite
Andrey Melnichenko, Russia’s wealthiest fertiliser producer, recently gave a rare interview to The Economist in which he advocated ending one-man rule and opening Russia more widely to the outside world.
Although he did not explicitly call for Putin’s removal, his remarks were interpreted as an unusual signal of criticism coming from within Russia’s wealthy business elite.
Arkady Ostrovsky, a journalist with The Economist who spent several hours interviewing Melnichenko, believes the billionaire was expressing views shared by others among Russia’s richest business figures.
He described the changing attitude towards Russia’s future as a historic and political shift, arguing that many oligarchs increasingly feel the war has pushed the country into a dead end with little prospect of a sustainable future.
Analyst Alexandra Prokopenko also views Melnichenko’s interview as a message encouraging other members of the economic elite to speak more openly.
She noted that even the language used by oligarchs when referring to Putin has reportedly changed. Whereas they previously called him “the boss”, “the first one” or simply “VV”, some now privately refer to him as “grandfather”, a term Prokopenko says is used with a degree of contempt.
What would Russia look like after Putin?
If Putin were to leave office, Russia’s Constitution provides for Prime Minister Mikhail Mishustin to assume the presidency on an interim basis.
However, BBC’s sources identify three possible directions for the country: a democratic system, a new form of autocracy or a return to an oligarch-dominated political order similar to the one that emerged during the 1990s.
Democracy is considered the least likely of these scenarios by the people interviewed, given the weakening of state institutions during Putin’s rule.
For many oligarchs, a return to a system in which business elites exercise direct influence over political decision-making would be more attractive. Ostrovsky describes this possibility as a kind of “oligarchic republic”.
According to Prokopenko, wealthy Russians want to return to a period when their opinions mattered, their fortunes were protected and the rules governing business and politics were more predictable.
Some also favour a revival of political competition, with less repression, greater freedom of expression and genuine competition between political parties and politicians.
Nevertheless, expectations of immediate change remain limited.
American financier Bill Browder, one of the Kremlin’s most prominent critics, and US investor Michael Calvey, who previously operated a business in Russia and was arrested there in 2019, believe oligarchs are unlikely to take action against Putin while he remains in power.
Fear of imprisonment and the loss of their fortunes continues to keep them silent.
Browder went further, arguing that Putin could even order the killing of oligarchs if they dared to openly challenge his authority.
For now, while signs of dissatisfaction may be emerging within Russia’s economic elite, there is little indication that its wealthiest members are prepared to directly confront the Kremlin.
