EU Warns Serbia’s Student List: Change of Government Does Not Erase Commitments to Kosovo

RKS NEWS
RKS NEWS 9 Min Read
9 Min Read

The European Union has made clear that Serbia’s political transition cannot be used to walk back commitments made in the Brussels dialogue with Kosovo, after the Student List announced plans to review the constitutionality of agreements reached between the two sides.

The Student List, which defeated the Serbian Progressive Party after 14 years in power, has signalled its intention to challenge agreements reached through the EU-facilitated dialogue. Its political programme explicitly rejects Kosovo’s independence and pledges to oppose the country’s membership in international organisations.

The position raises questions about whether Serbia’s new political leadership intends to honour commitments already undertaken in the normalisation process.

In a response to Radio Free Europe (RFE/RL), Kosovo’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Diaspora reiterated that Kosovo is an independent and sovereign state and that its independence is irreversible.

“Kosovo is an independent and sovereign state, and its independence is irreversible,” the ministry said.

Under the 2023 Agreement on the Path to Normalisation, Serbia committed not to oppose Kosovo’s membership in international organisations. The parties also agreed on an implementation plan, including commitments to respect each other’s territorial integrity and national symbols.

The Student List has also threatened legal action against what it describes as representatives responsible for concluding and implementing agreements it considers unconstitutional and harmful to Serbia.

EU: Serbia remains bound by its commitments

The European Union, which facilitates the dialogue between Pristina and Belgrade, has stressed that the outcome of Serbia’s elections does not change the obligations undertaken by either side.

“The results of the parliamentary elections in Serbia do not change the fundamentals of the EU-facilitated dialogue, nor the obligations undertaken by the parties,” an EU spokesperson told RFE/RL following the Student List’s victory.

Brussels expects Serbia to remain constructively engaged in the dialogue, fulfil its commitments and contribute to the normalisation of relations with Kosovo.

Serbia continues to refuse to recognise Kosovo’s independence. Since the dialogue began in 2011, the parties have reached dozens of agreements covering freedom of movement, the integration of the judiciary and police, energy, telecommunications, diploma recognition and the position of the Serb community in Kosovo.

Kosovo: Recognition must be at the centre of normalisation

Kosovo’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Diaspora said that lasting normalisation with Serbia could only be achieved if mutual recognition formed the basis of the process.

“Only on this basis can European relations of good neighbourliness be built. We remain committed to a dialogue that helps achieve this goal and enables the region to overcome recurring tensions and move towards lasting peace and sustained cooperation,” the ministry said.

The ministry warned that the Student List’s position on Kosovo risks deepening the divisions that the dialogue is intended to overcome.

“The Student List’s promise of political renewal in Serbia sounds unconvincing when its programme officially expresses the same territorial ambitions that characterised the previous government’s policy towards the Republic of Kosovo. They consider our country part of Serbia, explicitly define this as a political objective and promise to block our membership in international organisations,” the ministry said.

The statement highlights the contradiction between the Student List’s promises of political change and its commitment to maintaining Serbia’s longstanding claims over Kosovo.

Serbian Constitutional Court chief questions possibility of reversing agreements

Vladan Petrov, president of Serbia’s Constitutional Court, told RFE/RL in a written response that, in his view, reversing the situation created by agreements already implemented by Serbia would be almost impossible.

Petrov, who emphasised that he was expressing a personal opinion, said Serbia would have a constitutional basis for unilaterally withdrawing from the dialogue only if the Constitutional Court reversed its 2014 position and treated the agreements as international treaties.

In 2014, Serbia’s Constitutional Court rejected a request to review the constitutionality and legality of the First Brussels Agreement, classifying it as a political agreement rather than an international treaty.

“However, I repeat that, whatever their nature, the Republic of Serbia has been implementing them fully for a long time. It is therefore reasonable to ask what practical consequences such a decision could have, even if we consider it hypothetically,” Petrov said.

Following its electoral victory, representatives of the Student List also called for the resignations of several senior institutional officials, including Petrov.

What would a review of the agreements achieve?

Bogoljub Milošavljević, a professor of constitutional law in Serbia, said it remains unclear how the Student List intends to review the agreements reached through the dialogue with Kosovo or what it hopes to achieve.

“I do not believe that any steps would be taken that contradict the Student List’s goals and plans for moving closer to the European Union. A review [of the agreements within the dialogue on normalisation of relations with Kosovo] must have a purpose, because the previous government did all kinds of things,” he told RFE/RL.

Dušan Janjić of the Belgrade Forum for Ethnic Relations interpreted the announcement as an attempt to call for partnership with the EU and a minimum level of respect. He does not expect the Student List to take the matter to Serbia’s Constitutional Court.

Janjić argued that, from a constitutional perspective, both Kosovo and Serbia would benefit from a pause in the dialogue to establish the conditions for partnership and resume negotiations on a new basis.

“Let us not rush. Let us lay the foundations for continuing the dialogue,” he said.

He added that the Constitutional Court’s 2014 ruling remains in force and cannot simply be reopened.

Kosovo remains a test of Serbia’s promised political change

Political analyst Artan Muhaxhiri, based in Pristina, described the Student List’s position on Kosovo as a populist narrative that contradicts Serbia’s stated ambitions of moving closer to the European Union.

Muhaxhiri said the Student List has an opportunity to bring substantial positive changes to Serbian society, but risks wasting that opportunity by engaging in what he described as an irrational and ultimately futile attempt to rewrite history in the context of Kosovo.

“The success of their progressive ideas for the emancipatory political and sociocultural transformation of Serbia will depend on how realistic their approach is to the most difficult and sensitive processes. Relations with Kosovo should be among their main priorities,” he told RFE/RL.

He suggested that the upcoming presidential elections in Serbia, due by the end of the year, may be the only explanation for the Student List’s current position on Kosovo.

Muhaxhiri warned that dialogue cannot move forward unless the Student List changes its approach towards Kosovo.

Ultimately, the Student List faces a clear political test: whether its promises of democratic renewal will extend to abandoning Serbia’s territorial claims against Kosovo and respecting the commitments already made by Belgrade. A change of government does not erase international obligations, and a new political movement cannot credibly claim to represent democratic change while defending the same policies that have kept relations between Kosovo and Serbia in a state of confrontation.