Ireland’s presidency of the Council of the European Union has proposed reducing the probation period for new member states from 15 to 10 years, with the possibility of extending it by another five years, as EU governments prepare to finalise their position on new safeguards for future members.
In recent weeks, EU member states have been discussing how to introduce stronger safeguards proposed by the European Commission in early October. These include a probation period during which newly admitted countries could potentially have their voting rights suspended.
The Irish government, which is leading the negotiations, has circulated a draft document outlining the initial positions of member states. EU ambassadors are expected to discuss it on Wednesday as part of preparations for Montenegro’s accession treaty.
“The Presidency proposed a duration of ten years, with the possibility of a five-year extension. While there is broad support for this proposal, a number of member states continue to call for a longer period of 15 years, citing the need to ensure an effective deterrent or response to possible backsliding over a longer period after accession,” the document states, according to Euronews.
Ireland acknowledges that member states remain divided over several key aspects of the proposed safeguards. Some governments oppose triggering institutional protections over violations of the principle of sincere cooperation, arguing that such breaches could be difficult to assess objectively.
“Member states have highlighted the importance of suspending voting rights as a possible measure under this safeguard in cases of particularly serious violations. However, a small number of member states oppose such an option,” the document adds.
Five founding EU members, led by the Netherlands, have called for stricter safeguards to enable the bloc to respond more quickly to the emergence of another leader similar to Hungary’s Viktor Orbán.
Meanwhile, the Friends of the Western Balkans group, including Italy, are advocating a more tailored approach that would avoid placing new member states in an unequal position compared with existing members.
The draft also raises questions about how long accession-related delays should last and whether they should depend on an assessment of a candidate country’s readiness at the time of membership.
One option would be to impose an initial one-year delay, with the possibility of extending it by another year through a majority vote until the situation improves.
The Irish presidency also acknowledges that further discussions are needed on the decision-making process. The European Commission proposed activating the mechanism unless a qualified majority of member states objects.
While some governments support this so-called reverse qualified majority voting, others argue that measures of such importance should require unanimity. As a possible compromise, the presidency has suggested introducing a restricted simple-majority voting procedure.
The Commission has also proposed a monitoring mechanism to ensure that candidate countries fulfil their commitments before formally joining the bloc, with the possibility of postponing accession in the most serious cases.
According to the draft, there is broad support for monitoring fundamental areas before accession, including EU values, the rule of law and judicial independence.
However, several member states also want the monitoring process to include alignment with the EU’s Common Foreign and Security Policy. Such alignment has increasingly become an important instrument for preventing candidate countries from drifting into the sphere of influence of foreign powers.
The document also identifies general support for closer engagement with countries approaching membership when safeguard measures are proposed. It suggests linking pre-accession monitoring with the postponement clause, allowing monitoring to continue if accession is delayed.
Some member states have also called for a post-accession monitoring mechanism. However, the Irish presidency has left the proposal out of the draft legislation, citing concerns that it could duplicate existing measures.
Regarding the procedure for triggering an accession delay, the document describes a clear division among member states between those favouring restricted majority voting and those insisting on unanimity.
As a possible solution, the presidency has proposed an optional clause allowing postponement through qualified majority voting in areas of particular concern. However, questions remain over whether this approach would also apply to violations of EU values.
“The duration of a postponement remains a divisive issue. Some member states have called for a maximum period of one to three years, while others have argued that postponement should remain in place until the situation has improved,” the document states.
Sector-specific safeguards
Regarding sector-specific safeguards, the draft indicates considerable support for the Irish presidency’s compromise of a 10-year period, extendable by a further five years.
Nevertheless, significant divisions remain between countries seeking a 15-year period and those advocating a shorter duration of three to five years.
“Most member states have supported the Presidency’s proposal to strengthen an extension clause so that it can be used where measures have been taken during the first nine years and sufficient grounds have been demonstrated,” the document adds.
The discussions are particularly important for Western Balkan countries, including Montenegro, which is advancing in its EU accession process, as well as other candidates such as Albania, Serbia, North Macedonia, Kosovo and Bosnia and Herzegovina.
The proposed safeguards could significantly shape the conditions under which future countries join the European Union and the rights they receive following membership.
